Jump to content

2012: Grade the Player Exercise


Tony-OH

Recommended Posts

Like last year, here is your chance to grade out and discuss each player on the roster for 2012. The grades should be given in consideration to the player's role, and not necessarily the players worth. In other words, Troy Patton could grade out higher than Wei-Yin Chen even though Chen was a more valuable pitcher but Patton may have more effective in his role.

This is a great place to posts stats, highlights and anything and will give us a good record to look back on in the future. Due to the late start, I will post three players a day and give each player two weeks to be voted on.

Graded Players: (Grades as of Oct 29)

Robert Andino - D

Jake Arrieta - D

Luis Ayala - B

Wilson Betemit - C

Zach Britton - D

Endy Chavez

Wei-Yin Chen - B

Chris Davis

Miguel Gonzalez - A

Kevin Gregg - F

Jason Hammel - B

JJ Hardy - C

Tommy Hunter - C

Jim Johnson - A

Steve Johnson - A

Adam Jones - B

Matt Lindstrom

Manny Machado - A

Nick Markakis - B

Brian Matusz - C

Nate McLouth B/A

Darren O'Day - A

Troy Patton - B

Mark Reynolds - C

Joe Saunders - B

Pedro Strop - B

Chris Tillman - B

Matt Wieters - B

A

Miguel Gonzalez

Jim Johnson

Steve Johnson

Manny Machado

Darren O'Day

Nate McLouth

B

Luis Ayala

Wei-Yin Chen

Chris Davis

Jason Hammel

Adam Jones

Matt Lindstrom

Nick Markakis

Troy Patton

Joe Saunders

Pedro Strop

Chris Tillman

Matt Wieters

C

Wilson Betemit

JJ Hardy

Tommy Hunter

Brian Matusz

Mark Reynolds

D

Robert Andino

Jake Arrieta

Zach Britton

F

Endy Chavez

Kevin Gregg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is a great place to posts stats, highlights and anything and will give us a good record to look back on in the future. Due to the late start, I will post three players a day and give each player two weeks to be voted on.

I'm fine with a late start. Hopefully we start this sometime in November next year! :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Like last year, here is your chance to grade out and discuss each player on the roster for 2012. The grades should be given in consideration to the player's role, and not necessarily the players worth. In other words, Troy Patton could grade out higher than Wei-Yin Chen even though Chen was a more valuable pitcher but Patton may have more effective in his role.

This is a great place to posts stats, highlights and anything and will give us a good record to look back on in the future. Due to the late start, I will post three players a day and give each player two weeks to be voted on.

Graded Players:

Jason Hammel

Jim Johnson

Adam Jones

Thanks, great tradition.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Grading Breakdown:

A

Miguel Gonzalez

Jim Johnson

Steve Johnson

Manny Machado

Darren O'Day

Nate McLouth

B

Luis Ayala

Wei-Yin Chen

Chris Davis

Jason Hammel

Adam Jones

Matt Lindstrom

Nick Markakis

Troy Patton

Joe Saunders

Pedro Strop

Chris Tillman

Matt Wieters

C

Wilson Betemit

JJ Hardy

Tommy Hunter

Brian Matusz

Mark Reynolds

D

Robert Andino

Jake Arrieta

Zach Britton

F

Endy Chavez

Kevin Gregg

As I said in multiple polling threads, I'm very shocked that only 2 of the core 5 relievers (JJ, O'Day, Strop, Ayala, Patton) got A's. In my mind, the bullpen's consistency was the number one contributing factor to the team's success in 2012 and I gave all 5 relievers with 50+ inning a grade of A in the polls. The bullpen wasn't great because of 2 men... it was great because of the consistency of all 5 plus a few others who chipped in when necessary.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • In continuance of the discussion in the Bradisch thread re: Cowser as an "elite" OF: I think as the game slows for him he will be an plus defender in LF, hopefully with the Orioles.  However I argued his arm is not yet reliable and while there are little or no stats available that measure accuracy (as opposed to velocity) Savant places him around ~90th among OF's for the most important stat-advance attempts-far behind Hays whose arm is much more respected at #10, Tony and even Mullins "noodle arm" rate much higher.  https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/leaderboard/baserunning?type=Fld&sortColumn=rate_safe&sortDirection=asc  In each of the measurable arm metrics (other than velocity) he is far from "elite".  For advances/attempts to advance above average/succesful advances he is around ~90 in MLB and last among Orioles OF. When you juxtapose Hays's numbers onto CC one thing is evident-Hays has a well earned rep and guys generally don't run on him-guys at this point don't respect CC's arm.
    • I suspect it's because Urias has been hitting much better. I think Westburg/Mateo is better defensively, but it's not a big gap. Good chance this will be a close, low-scoring game. I like having Mateo on the bench in a close game so he can create a run, and some havoc, as a pinch-runner (especially when Mullins is in the starting lineup). Though it doesn't show in the boxscore, his feints from first base were a big factor yesterday.
    • Without doing any research this has been a feeling I have had too.    It is almost like the bats are trained for world class competition but when .475 clubs throw today's Joe Saunderses it can mess up the calibration. Throwing Cody Bradford and Andrew Heaney against the Orioles lineup probably isn't a sustainable October strategy. The hitting pitching balance Elias has kept so far, I agree it is more on Gunnar and Adley to lead the group beating the world's best pitchers. I hope Gunnar gets a Strahm rematch today after yesterday's first ball hack.    If the World Series is 7 close games, Gunnar probably sees Strahm 4-5 times.
    • “Preferred catcher” then. Would have been insanity to start McCann today.
    • Can Cook be a serviceable utility guy at the ML level?  His offensive numbers are better at Triple-A than in previous minor league seasons.
    • Because it’s a RHP, Urias has been hitting well and Mateo offers speed off the bench if needed in late innings.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...